Managing a Seller's Appraisal Expectations

 Bubba Mills  |    November 10, 2016

Dogs have fleas. Postal workers have dogs. And REALTORS® have … well, appraisers. Yep, no matter who you are, what you do or where you live, life always presents its hurdles. 

For REALTORS®, that hurdle is often appraisals — especially after the housing bust. Today, appraisals can kill a deal faster than a REALTOR® can make a U-turn. 

And appraisals can cut both ways: they can put houses out of reach for buyers and force sellers to settle for a lower price. In fact, I just read a new report from Quicken Loans that said appraisals are coming in at an average of 1.56 percent lower than what refinancing homeowners expected in August.

Sure, 1.56 percent may not seem like a big gap, but it can still cause problems. Bob Walters, Quicken Loans chief economist, says that in some parts of the Midwest, where appraisals are averaging 2 to 3 percent less than what was expected, it can mean “a few more thousand dollars.” In other words, a true deal killer.

Of course, appraisals vary from region to region, but good REALTORS® know they need to be prepared for surprises — and they need to prep their clients too. The more you communicate with your clients, the better chance you have for a favorable outcome. 

So first and foremost, open the floodgates on information about appraisals with clients — tell them everything and discuss scenarios for low and high appraisals to reduce any potential stings. 

Here are six tips to ensure you and your sellers are on the same page when it comes to appraisals:

  1. Create an improvement to-do list: Long before the appraiser ever enters the picture, have an open talk with the seller about key improvements the home needs — inside and out — such as painting, landscaping, plumbing, structural issues, wiring and other features. Explain that any decisions not to improve may very well come back to haunt them during the appraisal. 
  2. Scrub-a-dub-dub: Yep, clean the home up one side and down the other. A fresh lawn mowing, room decluttering, window washing and floor polishing never hurt.
  3. Keep things professional: Request that the appraiser have a residential appraiser certification and a professional designation. An example is the Appraisal Institute’s senior residential appraiser designation. Many state licensing agencies make the names of appraisers who have been disciplined available online, so you can check out whether the appraiser your lender is using is on the list.
  4. Go local: One of the most common problems with appraisals arises from appraisers who aren’t local and aren’t familiar with a local market. You can request that the lender use an appraiser who is local or at least who comes from a neighboring county. 
  5. Be present at the appraisal: Greeting the appraiser not only shows your seller that you care, it also sends a message to the appraiser you’re a hands-on REALTOR® who expects professionalism. You can also hand over the list of improvements and other important information about the property and market. Comps come to mind in this scenario. Then give the appraiser room to work once the appraisal starts. 
  6. Review the appraisal thoroughly: You’d be surprised how often simple mistakes arise in appraisals. Give it a close eye and make sure the square footage, the number of rooms and other features are correct and then have the appraiser make any corrections. 


Bubba Mills is the CEO of Corcoran Consulting and Coaching Inc. (, 800-957-8353), an international real estate, mortgage and small business coaching company committed to helping clients balance success in business, while building value in life. Bubba Mills is a nationally recognized inspirational and education speaker, coach and mentor to the top real estate agents and mortgage companies. To find out more about Corcoran Consulting & Coaching, call 1-800-957-8353 or visit


Copyright 1998 - 2024 Wisconsin REALTORS® Association. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy   |   Terms of Use   |   Accessibility   |   Real Estate Continuing Education